United States · New York
Where to Stay in Brentwood, New York
Brentwood is a hamlet in the Town of Islip in Suffolk County, on Long Island in New York, outside New York City.
Find your area →
Where to stay in Brentwood
Not every neighbourhood fits every trip — here's what each one is good for.
Bethpage Ballpark anchors most visits. Brentwood spreads across roughly 28 square kilometres of the Town of Islip without a hotel district of its own, so a stay here means a room on one of the through roads rather than beside a square. Long Island sets the alternatives.
Bay Shore lies close, with its own churches on the heritage roll, and Islandia and Commack are near by too. The hamlet has no single centre to organise a stay around, and the churches on its roll, First Presbyterian Church among them, mark neighbourhoods instead. Choose by the day's errand.
A visit built around Bethpage Ballpark and Spaceplex works from anywhere in the hamlet, since the distances inside the Town of Islip are small and the drives short. History pulls the other way. The Carll House, the Carll Burr, Jr., House and St. Johns Episcopal Church and Cemetery reward a base on the older side, and the Commack United Methodist Church and Cemetery sits within the same run. New York City is the fallback for range.
Anyone wanting a wide choice of rooms stays there and treats Brentwood as the Long Island end of the trip.
About Brentwood
Long Island shapes everything here.
What is Brentwood known for?
Brentwood is the largest of the hamlets in Suffolk County outside New York City, a place whose named sites are churches and old houses rather than a civic centre. Baseball has a home at Bethpage Ballpark. Winganhauppauge keeps an older name on the same ground, and the Carll House stands among the oldest buildings the roll records.
What are the main landmarks in Brentwood?
Churches make up most of the roll. First Presbyterian Church, the Bay Shore Methodist Episcopal Church and the First Congregational Church of Bay Shore appear on it, together with the Commack United Methodist Church and Cemetery and St. Johns Episcopal Church and Cemetery. Bethpage Ballpark and Spaceplex pull a different crowd, and the Islandia Veterans Memorial Triangle and Winganhauppauge keep two more names in circulation.
Two houses close it. The Carll House and the Carll Burr, Jr., House stand for the families that held this ground before the Town of Islip filled in around them.
What is the history of Brentwood?
The year Brentwood began was never written down. Brentwood grew inside the Town of Islip rather than as a chartered place of its own, which is why the record here runs through buildings and names instead of founding dates. Winganhauppauge is one of those names.
It survives on the roll of local landmarks alongside the churches and houses, one of the names this corner of Suffolk County has kept. Families left the houses. The Carll House and the Carll Burr, Jr., House are what remains of that older settlement, standing among streets that filled in as Long Island built outward from New York City.
Congregations came with the growth. St. Johns Episcopal Church and Cemetery and the Commack United Methodist Church and Cemetery hold burial ground as well as worship space, and the Bay Shore Methodist Episcopal Church and the First Congregational Church of Bay Shore mark the neighbouring community's own line of building. Scale came last.
Brentwood became the largest of the hamlets on Long Island outside New York City, spread over roughly 28 square kilometres of the Town of Islip, without ever acquiring the civic apparatus of a city. The record stays in the buildings.
Where is Brentwood?
Long Island is the frame. Brentwood covers roughly 28 square kilometres of the Town of Islip, one part of the Suffolk County share of Long Island, in the northern temperate band. Neighbours press on every side.
Bay Shore, Islandia and Commack all lie within a short run, and New York City sits at the far end of the island, which keeps Brentwood inside the reach of the city without being part of it.
What is the climate of Brentwood?
Long Island keeps the edges off. Brentwood lies in the northern temperate band on an island, so the water around Suffolk County takes some of the sharpness out of both the cold months and the warm ones. Seasons still turn clearly.
Games at Bethpage Ballpark belong to the warmer half of the year, while Spaceplex and the churches on the roll carry the darker months without much fuss.
How do you get to Brentwood?
Reaching Brentwood is a matter of driving out along Long Island. Brentwood sits inside the Town of Islip with New York City at the other end of Long Island, and the run in from the city is the ordinary way to arrive. Neighbouring hamlets are minutes away.
Bay Shore, Commack and Islandia are all short drives, which puts Bethpage Ballpark, Spaceplex and the churches of the heritage roll within one day's circuit without much planning.
Good for
More cities in New York
Updated August 2026